How Many Times Can You Sell the Same Broken Game?

encore-headerIf at first you don’t succeed, keep selling the same product over and over again, in the hopes that customers will finally buy it out of curiosity. This seems to be the approach Nordic Games, Rainbow Studios, and THQ have taken with MX vs. ATV Supercross Encore, an entirely forgettable motocross racer that bares little resemblance to the phenomenal entries in the series from around a decade ago. Originally arriving on the PS3 and Xbox 360 as a budget-priced, bare-bones dirt bike bash before being ported to both the PC, as well as current generation consoles, Nordic are now set to release the same game for a third time – albeit with a slightly different set of tracks.

Though Nordic Games haven’t secured the official American Motorcycle Association license, and therefore will not paint the in-game banners in the colors of the Monster Energy Supercross Series, physical track designs for the annual championship – to the best of my knowledge – fall under a much easier to obtain license, and as a result MX vs. ATV Supercross Encore for the PS4 and Xbox One will be re-released in a manner akin to the old Monaco Grand Prix games on the Sega Dreamcast. They can’t call venues by their real names such as Lucas Oil Stadium or Sam Boyd Stadium, nor will the game’s championship mode fall under the Monster Energy Supercross namesake, but everyone who picks up the game will be greeted with the exact tracks the series visits. THQ also appear to be playing along with this grey area, as their own press release and box art mentions “officially licensed tracks”, but they are careful not to mention the AMA sanctioning body or Monster Energy – just that they’ve licensed “the same tracks the pros race on.”

It’s a pretty big deal for motorcross fans. Aside from the officially licensed Supercross titles on the original PlayStation from both 989 Sports and Electronic Arts, modern motorcross games typically rely purely on fantasy track layouts within a mix of both real-world and fantasy stadiums, and this turns the level of authenticity down a notch compared to other racing games available for each respective console. While sim racers are used to being given a platter of real life tracks to select from in each modern simulator, motorcross game developers have traditionally struggled to acquire licenses, creating an experience similar to rFactor 2, where you’re ripping around the MX vs. ATV equivalent to Joesville or Toban, instead of real circuits like Daytona and Laguna Seca. Sure, MX Superfly from many years ago had a handful of circuits from the national tour like Glen Helen and Washougal, and the Milestone MXGP series have landed the entire European championship license, but American Motorcross seems to be a bit of a great white buffalo when it comes to video games.

Yet finally acquiring a portion of the licenses required to produce some kind of authentic game based on the 2017 professional supercross season means jack shit if the underlying experience isn’t satisfactory.

reviewThe MX vs. ATV series used to be a formidable off-road racer, and right now, it’s anything but. Reviews such as the one above outline an experience that quite frankly isn’t worth spending money on, with Steam users claiming the PC version of Supercross Encore suffers from numerous performance issues and poor design choices or fundamental mechanics that haven’t been rectified after a little over a year on the market as a fully-priced product, with a portion of that year spent in Steam’s Early Access program to sort of “cheat” the negative reviews that obviously popped up. Though the game was shipped as a finished product for the PS3 and Xbox 360 in October of 2014, Nordic were still working on optimizing the game after it had landed in the hands of PC players an entire year later – leading the hardcore motocross gaming crowd to feel like elaborate beta testers.

This extremely negative YouTube review from motocross gaming personality The White Guy was uploaded in October of 2015, though he has continued to answer questions about the current state of MX vs. ATV Supercross Encore as recently as three weeks ago, indicating the game is a pointless addition to any motocross fan’s library.

ayyIt’s really not in a good state from a gameplay perspective, and to make matters worse, rather than fixing the complaints the community have made about the title, they’ve pushed out $150 CDN worth of DLC for the game.

insane-dlcAll of this, for a motocross game that quite simply doesn’t meet a base level of quality customers have every right to expect from their transaction. Again, Nordic have more or less pushed aside all customer feedback in favor of announcing a special edition of the game bundled with an additional set of tracks inspired by the upcoming 2017 Monster Energy Season – also planning to release these tracks as downloadable content for those unwilling to buy a new copy of the game – and it all just looks really fucking bad.

Here you have a game where basically everyone whose bought it has said it needs serious work to be even remotely enjoyable both from a gameplay standpoint, as well as a technical standpoint, and the developer has responded by basically throwing such an absurd amount of downloadable content and re-releases at the user base it’s as if they’ve permanently stuck their fingers in their ears.

What’s sad about all of this, is that there aren’t multiple competing motocross games on the market, where if you don’t like one, you can check out the rival title. This isn’t one of those deals where you can go out and get a refund for Project CARS and exchange it for something similar in Assetto Corsa; your options as a motocross fan are exploring the modding scene of MX vs. ATV Reflex – which most want to move on from given it’s age – or diving into MX Simulator, a game far too hardcore for most motocross fans.

mx-vs-atv-supercross-10So while it’s cool for the Motocross community that Nordic are essentially putting out the first Supercross game in fifteen years to feature an entire championship full of authentic track layouts, in the end it doesn’t mean much considering the game itself hasn’t garnered any notable positive reception in the three years it’s been on the market. In fact, a lot of people hate it, and they’re deeming this gesture as a giant slap in the face to those holding out for a solid dirt bike game.


30 thoughts on “How Many Times Can You Sell the Same Broken Game?

      1. You mean ISI, the ones that fucked up their fossil sim so bad that they left the sinking ship and sold it to some other poor studio? Right, ISI…


        1. >Why would black men *Work on British Broadcasting Corporation* possibly want to hate Jeremy?


          Next time, learn about other acronyms about BBC that’s not that one.

          And forget about below, I’m too slow.


            1. And how about you?

              You know acronym of ABC, ESPN, NBC, CBS, CNN, FS1, but not BBC.

              Friend, if I talk about [Bernie Eccstone Unpoliteful word got censored], I have to ask Rick Allen or Anthony Davidson about the existance of PRCdotNet


              (Proof that most Americans don’t know shit about British Broadcasting Corporation)


    1. And also the American NASCAR Drivers in most contries (except MURICA, of course).

      The most hated, however, according to reddit vote, was Kyle Busch, and, according to most fans, Toyota.

      The latter had won the Manufacturer’s Award for the first time, also ending Chevy’s Streaks.

      So, you can say things that “threaten” everyone who don’t follow the liberal road of sim racing. Just because you can said that, doesn’t mean you aren’t manchild. You are: Mancries.


  1. “Two of my favorite things are my steering wheel and my Remington rifle.” -Dale Earnhardt, Sr.

    Seriously, while it’s arcade game, I could bring a rifle to shot at every developer who don’t listen to gaming commuity.

    For Senna sake! Please, fix, it, Nordic!


  2. A whole article dedicated to an arcadey racer, but at least you mentioned MX Simulator, James. I’m surprised you are aware of its existence at all.

    Instead of wasting time and space on this crap, you should have told more about MX Simulator and MX Bikes. Though I guess you prefer writing about crapware rather than about “eternal science projects”, which is basically every serious enough sim out there nowadays.


  3. I play MXGP and MXGP 2 by Milestone up and down since it´s the best motocross-package you can get nowadays by graphics, licenses, content and gameplay.

    Sure, MX Simulator and PiboSi´s thing have SIMULATION, but I don´t cling on such aged shit. The graphics are from 1985.


    1. You don’t cling on such aged shit like simulation? Looks like James here had about enough with simulation as well. Have fun with your Brick Rigs and other games with “graphics, licenses, content and gameplay”. Might as well try Call of Duty while at that.


Rap battles between users are encouraged; losers will be IP banned for 24 hours.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s