Payback is a Bitch

Ghost Games took a year off in an attempt to try and revamp EA’s aging Need for Speed franchise – the second time they’ve done so – but after the reveal of Need for Speed: Payback earlier this morning, I’m certainly left wishing they would have remained in some sort of extended hibernation, and spared us from the second-hand embarrassment of pushing a piece of software out that nobody asked for. Appearing to be set in a fictional rendition of Las Vegas, Nevada and the surrounding treacherous landscape – which is objectively a good mix of technical canyons and wide-open desert highways, so kudos to Ghost on the environment choice – Need for Speed: Payback will be the third action driving game in the long-standing virtual car culture franchise, following in the footsteps of Undercover and The Run, while also drawing inspiration from UbiSoft’s The Crew and narrative elements from Hollywood blockbuster The Fast and the Furious. In classic Electronic Arts fashion, the first official trailer shows absolutely zero live gameplay, but the ninety seconds spent introducing Payback at least establishes the underlying theme of what we can expect from Ghost Games this fall.

And unfortunately, it’s not what anybody wanted to see.

We’re introduced to an array of characters hell-bent on destroying each other before the footage shifts to a collection of scenes that imply they’ve teamed up and look eerily similar to what UbiSoft had produced in their promotional footage for The Crew, right down to specific drag, drift, and off-road variants of cars you’ll be able to purchase and upgrade throughout the duration of the offline campaign mode. It’s the lack of creativity that bothers me here, as with The Crew already having been out on the market for quite some time, Need for Speed blatantly copying what UbiSoft tried and ultimately failed with – to the point where characters in the trailer speak directly of a crew at least three times – indicates their public hiatus was for absolute jack shit; it’s like they’ve asked their teacher for extra time to finish a school project, only to come back with something that was blatantly copied from a friend who took the course a previous semester – and I’ll throw up some shots to display what I’m talking about here.

I won’t go so far as to call it outright theft – there’s only so many aftermarket parts you can put on a car – but if you’re going to take an entire year off to build something unique and exciting, coming back with what on the surface looks like a blatant rip-off of another game’s entire concept and premise is just really shitty, and before fans have even seen gameplay footage, they’re already against you because The Crew wasn’t very good in the first place, and they certainly didn’t want more of it.

promo screenshots

Need for Speed: Payback is a title that actively goes against what fans of the series have been requesting for several years – most notably a set of solid driving physics and freedom to just sort of fuck off and do whatever you wanted within the game world – also defeating the point of why they took a year off, and I cannot see this project ending in anything other than total failure with what Payback appears to bring to the table. The absolute last thing Need for Speed fans wanted from the franchise was a kind of action driving saga with heavy narrative elements and a variety of set pieces, and yet that’s exactly what Ghost have been constructing over the previous year or so.

And the reason I’m so critical of the series returning to an action driving experience, is because Need for Speed 2015 (as well as Rivals) received excessive criticism primarily for a physics engine that actively took control of the car away from the player, and users on Reddit and other Need for Speed community websites made their voices loud and clear that improved driving physics needed to be priority number one. That kind of experience isn’t synonymous with action driving games.

The reality is that people have been asking for something akin to Underground 2 or DriveClub, where the vehicle physics are a gameplay element that can be learned, understood, and mastered over a period of time so the core racing portion is enjoyable and rewards raw driving skill, rather than manipulated by a hand of God at any given second to ensure scripted sequences – such as the trailer explosions and car chases seen in the reveal trailer – follow a very strict chain of events and don’t result in absolute chaos that only vaguely follows the narrative like we’re used to in Grand Theft Auto missions. So for Ghost to go the action driving route, therefore guaranteeing the driving model will be nothing but perplexing and downright frustrating in the name of smooth story-driven set pieces, means they’ve taken all this time off to outright ignored why people panned their last release – when the entire point of taking time off in the first place was to sit down and analyze what people wanted. Refusing to even take into account valid criticisms of your last title and make changes based on what your core fans want is of course a fantastic plan of action for any major video game developer and certainly won’t lead to a predicament later on down the line.

Payback also indicates Ghost Games couldn’t even be bothered to study the history of Need for Speed. Three times in the Xbox 360 era of the franchise Need for Speed experimented with heavy narrative elements and an abundance of scripted sequences akin to what we’re seeing in Payback, resulting in two of the worst games in the series from a critical standpoint, as well as a movie that was a gigantic flop and quickly dismissed as a B-grade Fast & Furious knock-off.

Ghost continuing to pursue this style of driving game despite fans and critics alike reacting in an overwhelmingly negative manner to previous titles featuring the same subject matter is the actual definition of insanity; and that’s just Need for Speed we’re talking about. Reception to The Crew, another open-world driving game that seems to have inspired Payback, received very similar feedback even on our own website, as users explicitly wanted the heavy narrative elements pushed front and center – just like Payback – to go away so they could focus on the few enjoyable parts of the game.

Continuing to push into this direction when customers clearly didn’t respond to it well in 2008, didn’t enjoy it when it popped up again in 2011, didn’t want it in 2014 on the big screen, and again didn’t have nice things to say about it in 2015 when it came from UbiSoft, after taking a year off and promising the next Need for Speed will be built with the fans in mind, will make it very hard to sympathize with Ghost when this too ends up being a disaster.

I do not understand why an open-ended street racing game featuring police chases, adequate driving physics, and a big map that let you buy cars and hire drivers to race alongside you whether it be online or offline was so impossibly difficult to produce, the team instead resorted to a racing game with physics people have panned on no less than four separate occasions and heavy narrative elements that the core audience have already voiced loud and clear that they don’t appreciate and would not like to see return.

Ghost took a year off in the name of the fans, and returned with something the fans have explicitly voiced they didn’t want, also managing to ignore all of the times similar efforts in the franchise have failed in the past. This is not a developer you should support with your money, and a developer you should not sympathize with when Need for Speed: Payback inevitably comes crashing down due to the complaints that will now stretch almost a decade in lifespan. After the disaster that was Need for Speed 2015, I was hoping Ghost would take a good, hard look at what made previous iterations of the franchise such astounding products that resonated with multiple generations of gamers, but instead I am only left genuinely angry by this reveal, and questioning what in the absolute fuck is going on at Electronic Arts to greenlight this sort of creative direction.

 

Advertisements

34 thoughts on “Payback is a Bitch

  1. Wew, another boring generic “story” game with cars in it. Ghost Games are intentionally digging NFS’ grave, and it’s funny how the last few good games were the “Shift” games, ones that were panned just because it didn’t have open world.

    Like

    1. yeah yeah, physics, but that’s not the point, most of the nfs games around that time had shitty physics anyways, so basically the only reason why the good games were panned were because no cops or open world.

      Like

      1. More like reading tea leaves. Also Ghost Games probably heard enough complaints about the physics, so it would be idiotic for them to not try to vastly improve them.

        Also Hi James, you forgot to log in.

        Like

  2. Need For Speed games with a story/narrative:
    – Porsche Unleashed (Factory Driver mode)
    – Underground
    – Underground 2
    – Most Wanted
    – Carbon
    – ProStreet
    – Undercover
    – The Run
    – Rivals
    – Need For Speed
    – Payback

    So, that’s quite a few. Yeah Undercover, The Run and Need For Speed were more intrusive than most (especially The Run with the QTE sections).

    Like

    1. I really liked the storyline of NFS:MW ’05. It was just the right level of story; it gave you excuses for ridiculously cool setpieces, had endearingly corny dialogue, and that was it. You had all the justification you needed and all the FMV trash-talking you could hope for from a Need for Speed game, and nothing else.

      Like

  3. I played all the NFS games, from the very first until Most Wanted 2005. After that I either grew up or the stories got worse. Maybe both. If they could drop the goddamn awful narratives, solidify the core gameplay of open world fun and racing events I’d try another NFS game.

    This is off-topic but I always thought Porsche Unleashed was criminally underrated, not to mention overshadowed by the mudslide of EA’s mediocrity that followed since its release. I doubt anyone would want another single manufacturer title these days, but goddamn… I truly believe that game devs could learn a lot from the in-menu game content in NFS:PU. The rich model history, glorious photographs of the interior and exterior, as well as the interactive showroom brought the vehicles to life before you ever got it on the track–that’s saying something considering we’re talking about a car company renowned for its incrementalism.

    Fuck. The nostalgia is real right now.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Plus the physics and track design were friggin’ great. Driving through the Alps stage and seeing it get more snowy to the point of thick fog and beautiful, white-bluish snowy environment is magical even today. Absolutely stellar art design.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. I was just massively under-whelmed, and the trailer did not make me enthusiastic at all. So much so that I had to create this cynical trailer reaction to counter all the over-hype being produced and be honest with how I felt about it. And judging from my like-to-dislike ratio & comments, I might have hurt a few fee-fees because someone DARED to have a different opinion than them. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_JiRO1a02uA

    NFS and Sonic have something in common: their publishers keep trying to change the core identity of its games every release, and I’m just sick of it.

    Don’t get me started on the viral marketers. BlackPanthaa already knew about the game ahead of everyone else and uploads at the exact time as NFS, so you know his integrity as an “honest” YouTuber has been compromised. God knows who else may be shilling for EA.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Another cringy story for a NFS game. There’s no reason to play these games anymore when Forza Horizon 3 exists.

    Like

  6. NFS is arcade. Players wants to have fun. No simuation value or Just a bit more.
    For the author PC2 is a bitch, ripping off PC1 with Just some marketing addition.

    Like

  7. I thought the trailer was quite appealing at first and then got bogged down in plot. I just wanna hijack trucks and drive fast cars, not become some sort of globe-spanning criminal empire. The whole “progress upward and stop actually playing the driving game to play a soccer league coach simulator” game design thing does nothing for me.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. In general, Jews are not very creative people. Many of them steal and subvert other people’s ideas and attempt to take credit for them. Look at Mark Zuckerberg for example. He stole the original idea for Facebook and was eventually forced to settle a lawsuit for $65 million.

    Like

    1. Really? And you spouting the same tired crap we have been subjected to for years is creative? You are a piss poor example of the human species, the sooner you lot shut up and fuck off the better. Also before some gormless idiot comes in saying baited, it’s about time people spoke up about this shit. Get this crap off the site unless you actively support it.

      Liked by 1 person

  9. And can you believe people actually defend underground, as being anything but absolute fucking trash.

    I paid $12 on PSN last year and still feel ripped off. I couldn’t imagine how pissed I’d be if I actually spent $60 on it. It’s just fucking terrible.

    Like

  10. I miss the days of Need for Speed being the endearingly ridiculous franchise instead of a plot-heavy, weirdly grimdark one. I play sims for realism and I play arcade titles because I want over-the-top thrill-a-minute silly stuff. NFS kinda captured that magic of, like, playing with Hot Wheels. It started with beautiful concept cars and exciting police chases, then went to such a perfect hyper-exaggeration of 2000’s tuner culture it ends up more hilarious than dated in hindsight, and then escalated to police Lamborghinis firing EMPs at hypercars.

    The Run signaled a change that wasn’t for the better, but didn’t go away, starting with a paper thin plot about the mob and having you get shot at, and then Rivals had the racing side of the career end with you frickin’ dying in a car crash, and then even rival series The Crew had you avenging your brother who was murdered by a street gang…

    Like, none of that accomplishes giving me more cars, or letting me race cars, or letting me be happy.

    (I will also plug the Wii version of Need for Speed: The Run real quick, though, for being a wonderfully excessive comic-book story that works way, way better than the paper-thin plot of the main console versions. The gameplay isn’t necessarily better, but the B-team wrote a better story at the least.)

    Like

  11. Admittedly the video is uninviting to say the least , but with no gameplay actually shown it’s pretty dam hard to gauge what we are getting , kids will still love it I’m sure .

    Certainly hard to get excited from what has been seen for the last 10 years from the franchise.

    Like

  12. My little birdie has brought to my attention that wmd members who had paid good money to become one. Are being banned for criticizing pcars2. And jet no article has bin made here. Sounds like something prc should be all over. And jet you say that you’re sponsoring by Ian bell hasn’t shut you up…………….. Make one wander.

    Like

  13. NFS – both the game series and the fanbase – is basically the Sonic the Hedgehog of racing games at this point, with developers constantly changing ideas every game AND the unpleasable fanbase thinking what era/game was the best – and what the developers should cling to.

    Liked by 1 person

      1. No matter how good a latest installment of a long running franchise is (or a movie, or a new album of a music group), there will always be lots of people bitching about it. Sometimes it’s justified, other times it’s nothing more than nostalgia fetishism.

        Like

    1. Agreed at the moment ea are a little lost with the need for speed franchise , it is dieing a slow death death much like call of duty , its becoming painfull .

      Like

  14. Based on the last two installments (PC), it will probably be a buggy game that regularly crashes, has almost no controller support, and a physics engine that belongs in a cartoon with a big ACME label on it.

    Like

Ratio of vowels to consonants will be monitored. Post at your own discretion.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s