Baja: Edge of Control HD is Spectacularly Broken [Updated]

There’s been a lot of animosity directed at THQ Nordic from the motocross gaming community, but I’ve never gotten to experience first-hand the justification for it until this morning. I was really hoping to spend a large portion of the day playing Baja: Edge of Control HD as I have no problem listing it as one of my favorite Xbox 360 racers, and could not wait to play a remastered rendition on modern hardware – but after purchasing the game twice, and requesting a refund once, I’m left pretty disgusted at the kind of bullshit THQ Nordic have pulled here. To put it plain and simple, Baja: Edge of Control HD should not have been released, as there are pretty mind-blowing controller problems across multiple platforms.

Initially, I purchased the game on Steam, as it’s about eight dollars cheaper than the PlayStation 4 version for unexplained reasons. The game honestly isn’t a very big download, I think I recall seeing it somewhere between four and eight gigabytes, meaning it was ready for consumption in around seven minutes. This may sound pitiful by today’s standards, but the actual game itself is quite good; with over 170 vehicles split between ten classes, and upwards of one hundred tracks in both circuit and point to point format, Baja as a complete package back in the day was a pretty exciting niche offering provided you could get over the atrocious graphics – hence the point of the HD version in the first place.

My own personal hype train was derailed when I discovered that on the Steam version, the external controller config applet doesn’t actually work. By default, keyboard keys are mapped to all of the buttons on the Xbox 360 controller, obviously so you can bust out a controller and reconfigure everything to your desired layout – which 99% of the time you’re just going to mirror the stock layout and just ensure all the respective axis’ are correct. Here is where things get absolutely insane – the applet crashes upon trying to do so. You know, the basic process of clicking on “Throttle” and pressing R2 to map that button as your gas pedal? Crashes the applet. One hundred percent serious here.

So obviously that means no wheel support either, as while there’s indeed a tab you can click to configure your racing wheel prior to launching the game, and graphically it is a nice applet, again rebinding crashes the thing. Playing Edge of Control HD on the PC right now consists of pressing the “O” key as your throttle, and using the arrow keys to turn.

With little activity in the forums to give me faith that this would be fixed, I promptly requested a refund for the game on Steam, and purchased the allegedly superior PS4 version, which a whole bunch of YouTube gaming channels have been demonstrating for THQ Nordic over the past little bit leading up to the game’s launch. I figured that maybe Sony would hold these guys to a higher standard, and I could have faith that both a standard DualShock 4, as well as a Logitech G29, would work out of the box. I wasn’t expecting a great driving experience – this is a weird quasi-simulator, with detailed mechanical failures yet a larger than life driving model – but as I mentioned before, I loved this game back in the day and was jacked that the graphics are no longer a blurry mess, so whatever, in my opinion they fixed the game’s biggest problem and I’d have a cool sorta-casual off-road game in my library.

The Logitech G29 works, only if by the definition of “works”, do you split hairs and have an impromptu debate over what is considered “working.” I can turn the wheel from left to right, and it indeed goes the full nine hundred degrees. I can rev the engine by pushing the throttle. I can also push in the clutch and rev the engine from a standstill. The brake pedal, however, is stuck at one hundred percent input no matter what you do. It is almost impossible to leave the starting line unless you constantly mash the clutch and throttle in succession. If not, the truck hangs on the starting line at 2300 RPM and slides sideways. This game is $39.99 on the PlayStation Store.

 

If, by some act of god the brake pedal doesn’t stick – about 50% of the time for me – other issues arise when you do get moving. The change camera button has been mapped to the PS4 Share button, and the share functionality overrides the ability to change the camera, so if you drive with a wheel, you’re stuck in chase view. There isn’t even a way to change it in the options. The wheel sensitivity slider also warrants no change, meaning a lot of the vehicles in the game require gigantic steering inputs just to take gentle corners.

What makes this strange, is that I can plug my Logitech G29 into my PlayStation 3, boot up the original Edge of Control, and it works flawlessly. The sensitivity is better, the button mapping allows you to change the camera, and the brake pedal does not stick. The problem I have in doing so, is that the PlayStation 3 rendition was dogshit in comparison to the superior Xbox 360 version due to mammoth framerate troubles, which is why a remaster of this title was justified in the first place. Furious? Absolutely. When it comes to old games receiving a high definition upgrade, a reasonable outcome is to discover that it just ain’t like it used to be, or that the nostalgia goggles are almost blinding to a game’s faulty mechanics. But with Baja: Edge of Control HD, sometimes I can’t even get off the starting line when trying the title on multiple platforms. The PC version’s controller config tool crashes upon trying to rebind anything, and the PS4 version features incomplete wheel support.

Can you play with a standard DualShock 4? Well, yes. The problem arises in just how long some of Baja’s marquee events happen to be. While you can indeed slug it out in five lap circuit races that are on-par with what you’d expect from a traditional off-road racer, the enjoyable part of Baja comes in tacking the ultra-long point to point stages chained together to make up the sanctioned SCORE 250, 500, or 1000 mile races. If you’d like to drive for upwards of two hours with a gamepad, by all means be my guest, but I sure as hell don’t.

This is really just the start of the game’s fundamental problems. Occasionally, collision detection gets disabled during a race, resulting in pretty comical moments where you can just drive through the field at your own free will as seen below. In other situations, the game’s dashboard camera generates a giant black artifact across the screen, making it impossible to drive in anything other than chase view. Split screen racing with a friend causes the game to lose all sound until you restart the application. The original game did not have these problems; for the most part it was a solid, albeit highly obscure trophy truck racer.

The motocross gaming community have had similar problems dealing with THQ Nordic, but due to the popularity of an older title – MX vs. ATV Reflex – they’ve for the most part been able to avoid this kind of ineptitude by merely playing a different game. For those of us who loved Baja, and there were a lot of us, we don’t really have a choice here – we really needed the remastered version to be 100% functional. Right now, it’s not.

Advertisements

48 thoughts on “Baja: Edge of Control HD is Spectacularly Broken [Updated]

        1. This is so fucking disappointing.

          They had two fucking jobs : Fix high speed physics and make the graphics not look like they are presented through a thick filter of pea soup.

          I still play this on 360 all the time. There’s still nothing like this god damn game what a shame.

          I’ve been looking to throw money at them since I heard about this remake because I just couldn’t fucking believe they picked this game up for a remake, and on PC, no less, modders, multiplayer, all the things.

          Now what?

          GET TO WORK GOD DAMN

          Liked by 1 person

            1. I did!

              But the attention needed to throttle control was not as significant as in Edge of Control. High speed off-road is all about weight and throttle and while Edge of control slightly exaggerated those to some extent, you knew, while playing the game, that they focused on the right aspects of it to keep you on your toes and it had a legit feel that even the dirt games lacked.

              I have serious problems getting over Edge of Control.

              Liked by 1 person

            2. I could swear I typed my OP at the bottom of the page, but it looks like it posted a reply to your post.

              That’s weird. How are you doing? I have beer in the fridge.

              Like

  1. I enjoyed dirt 4 for a short period of time , hated the rear wheel drive cars and the generated tracks but completely enjoyed the rally cross portion of the game , after seeing comments from inside sim racing , team vvv and now this chappy ” I’m in ” for WRC for the first time .

    A Good month !

    F1 2017
    WRC 7
    Project cars 2

    As for Nascar heat 2 and Baja ” I’m definitely not in” .

    Liked by 1 person

          1. It’s just that you two spend your entire time here worrying and speculating about motives, personalities, feelings, identities, etc. There’s almost never any input about racing sims. Which makes you shitposters.

            But it’s more than that. It’s effeminate. It’s gossip. Nothing wrong with that. But I’m wondering if you recognize the irony of calling people “fags” while you do it.

            Like

            1. Here’s the facts: The comment section is the place to make fun of nerds like you who take playing video racing games way too serious. We pulled the strings and you danced for us. Man up and stop crying like the little bitch you are.

              Like

  2. You really have to give it to him ” missile command ” its pretty dam funny/ witty 🙂 , if you are old enough to know what missile command is or was .

    Like

  3. Shame we could have done with another decent off-road type game. Forza Horizon 3 still rules that space at the moment.

    What’s the verdict on WRC 7 James? Any PRC regulars tried it yet?

    Like

    1. I thought we knew better than to listen to people who are almost nine seconds off pace in their own league.

      (anecdotal: Sai set the World Record in Qualifying. This was my first time in the car.)

      Like

  4. Well, that’s a shame. Looked like a great opportunity to introduce new people to a classic; I hadn’t tried the original myself and was curious about this. I gotta wonder how they can drop the ball with every single game and stay in business.

    Like

  5. i have been playing this with a xbox controller in chase view just like back in the day. i don’t think this was ever meant to be played with a wheel. still one of my favorites’s

    Like

Ratio of vowels to consonants will be monitored. Post at your own discretion.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s